ZIMRA Audit Alert: The Danger of Submitting Nil returns while paying Rent

🚨 Audit Alert: The Danger of Submitting Nil Returns While Paying Rent

In the world of corporate compliance, few red flags are as prominent to the Zimbabwe Revenue Authority (ZIMRA) as the contradiction of a company declaring zero income (Nil Returns) while demonstrably incurring major operating expenses, such as rentals.

While ZIMRA mandates that even dormant companies must file Nil Returns, the moment a substantial expense like rent appears on the ledger, the company is signaling activity without declaring the corresponding revenue. This misalignment is a critical audit trigger, opening the business up to severe penalties, interest, and legal consequences.

1. The Audit Trigger: Inconsistency in Data

ZIMRA’s audit selection process is increasingly reliant on data matching across various tax heads. The core of the risk lies in the following data points:

• Income Tax/VAT Returns (The Nil Declaration): The company claims to have generated no revenue, resulting in zero tax liability.

• Withholding Tax (WHT) Returns (The Rental Payment Record): The company, as the tenant, is legally obliged to deduct and remit Withholding Tax on rental payments to the landlord (unless the landlord has a valid Tax Clearance Certificate). The submission of this WHT record (usually an REV5 return) proves a significant transaction has occurred.

The Fatal Question: ZIMRA will immediately ask: If the business is paying rent for premises, what activity is taking place there, and where is the resulting income?

2. The Direct Consequences of a ZIMRA Audit

Once this inconsistency triggers an audit, the financial and legal fallout can be devastating.

A. Income Imputation and Back Taxes

The auditor will not accept the Nil Return. They will use the rental expense as a benchmark to estimate a reasonable turnover that a business operating from that location, and paying that level of rent, should generate.

• Deemed Assessment: ZIMRA has the power to issue an estimated assessment based on best judgment. This estimate is often significantly higher than the company’s true, un-declared income, forcing the taxpayer into a difficult and costly objection process.

• Income Tax Liability: The estimated income is assessed for Income Tax, payable retrospectively.

• VAT Liability: If the deemed turnover exceeds the VAT registration threshold, the company will be registered for VAT (if not already), and the calculated VAT on the deemed sales will be charged, plus penalties, from the date of required registration.

B. Penalties and Interest

The penalties for failure to declare income or for evading tax are substantial and designed to deter non-compliance:⁴

• Additional Tax Penalty: If ZIMRA proves the Nil Return was filed with the intention to evade tax (wilful failure to submit correct returns), an additional tax penalty of up to 100% of the tax due can be imposed. This can double the tax bill immediately.

• Interest: Interest is charged on the unpaid tax amount, typically compounded, which rapidly escalates the debt.

• Late Submission Penalties: The failure to submit correct returns (even if a Nil Return was filed) will still attract a penalty for each outstanding return.

C. Loss of Tax Clearance (ITF 263)

A business with an outstanding tax debt, particularly one arising from an audit where fraud or gross negligence is established, will have its Tax Clearance Certificate (ITF 263) withheld or revoked.

• Cash Flow Crisis: Without a valid ITF 263, any other registered company paying the delinquent business for goods or services must legally withhold 30% of the payment and remit it to ZIMRA. This catastrophic reduction in cash flow often cripples operations.

• Operational Stoppage: A Tax Clearance is required for numerous essential functions, including securing government tenders, dealing with banks, and participating in foreign currency trade.

3. How to Legally Manage a Low-Revenue Business

If a company is genuinely in a start-up phase, temporarily inactive, or operating at a net loss, it must take proactive steps to document its position and avoid the audit trap:

1. Stop Renting Immediately: If the company is genuinely dormant and has no income, the first action should be to terminate the lease to stop incurring the audit-triggering expense.

2. Declare the Loss: If the company is trading but losing money, it must file a full Income Tax Return (ITF 12C), complete with financial statements that declare the rental expense and the zero or low revenue, resulting in a net loss—not a Nil Return. This is legal and deductible against future profits.

3. Document Non-Trading Status: If the business is paying rent for storage or as a holding expense while setting up, the company should keep meticulous board resolutions and records explaining the absence of income (e.g., waiting for machinery, pending regulatory approval).

4. WHT Compliance: Ensure that the Withholding Tax on the rental is consistently paid and correctly filed, as this shows compliance with transactional taxes, even if income tax is low.

Filing a Nil Return while incurring a deductible expense like rent is fundamentally dishonest to the tax authority. It converts a potential deductible loss into a massive, penalized tax liability.

Get in touch for our services.